Kelly Clarkson and Beyonce: Too Close for Comfort

There is a lot of buzz today surrounding Kelly Clarkson's new song Already Gone and its musical similarities to Beyonce's hit Halo. Although she performed Already Gone on Good Morning America this morning, Clarkson is claiming that the song is being released against her will. She seems to be blaming Ryan Tedder, the One Republic frontman who is the songwriter of both songs. It appears that Tedder submitted the same backing track to both artists, accounting for their very strong musical similarities.

Read the New York Magazine story and listen to both songs here.

This case brings to mind the story of how Bon Jovi's breakthrough hit You Give Love a Bad Name began life as If You Were a Woman and I Was a Man (yes, that's really the title) by Bonnie Tyler. In that instance Jon Bon Jovi, Richie Sambora and songwriter Desmond Child reworked the song Child had earlier written for Tyler into You Give Love a Bad Name. While not a big U.S. hit, If You Were a Woman and I Was a Man topped the charts in several European countries in early 1986. It preceded You Give Love a Bad Name's release on Bon Jovi's Slippery When Wet album by six months.

Here's the video for Tyler's song. See if it doesn't sound familiar: